AMSA Follies: The Duck Pond
Q: What’s bipedal, featherless, and quacks like a duck?
quacks representatives of the Association of Accredited Naturopathic Medical Colleges.
That’s right… AMSA sold them a booth at the 2011 convention, to say nothing of the smattering of naturopathic students in attendance as participants.
AMSA won’t quite take pharm money (more on that tomorrow), but they have no problem selling out to pseudoscience (that term is far too generous).
I went up to the booth and feigned ignorance as to what naturopathy is. I was told that they are “primary care physicians” who treat the “whole patient in a holistic way.” I pushed harder and harder, and for the longest time they continued to maintain that they’re “just like MD physicians.” Finally, one of their reps cracked, and poured forth the litany of quackery to which they subscribe: homeopathy, herbalism, acupuncture, therapeutic touch, and all sorts of other nonsense.
Fortunately, their written materials were more straightforward about their quackishness, though there were also some materials to recruit MD students for “integrative medicine” training at “Bastyr University“ in the Pacific Northwest (of course). Too bad they’re competing with AMSA’s own summer pseudoscience academy, whose flyers I also picked up.
For an organization that professes to support evidence-based medicine in other realms, and that ostensibly represents those students who are training to become applied scientists, this is really sad. The political gripes I might have with AMSA are one thing, but legitimizing quackery of this sort is truly beyond the pale. A poll of an unrepresentative convenience sample indicated that this is a non-partisan issue. “Open-mindedness” and “tolerance” are great, but when it comes to practices that don’t work, that mislead patients and that cast a pall on scientific medicine, organized medicine (AMSA included!) shouldn’t hesitate to take a stand.
If AMSA could be a forceful voice against pseudoscience much as they are a forceful voice for a variety of health policies with much less evidentiary support, they would be doing medicine, science, and patients a great service indeed.
I almost forgot, at the other end of the exhibition hall was the ayurvedic quack booth. I hope these pictures speak for themselves.
Contact the author
- Ah, #quebec, la belle province, where even snow removal is a criminal racket. bit.ly/JtTzOT 2 years ago
- @petersuderman Better to wean the moon from its dependence on dirty unreliable foreign planetary oil by 2100. Drill the Sea of Tranquility! 2 years ago
- @medrants Great post! If the US is really trying to "steal" doctors, it's failing miserably. bit.ly/yUxgtd bit.ly/zgOkuL 2 years ago
- RT @IJ: We just sued the #IRS. Watch our video to find out why: youtube.com/watch?v=0-1IEq… PLS RT!! 2 years ago
- Come on, Wordpress, "select all" does NOT mean "select every other paragraph." #fail 2 years ago
- More fun facts on how US healthcare compares to other countries, via @DisMgtCareBlog bit.ly/zMDcVH 2 years ago
- US infant and perinatal mortality not as bad as alleged by many on left, others. Via @ATuteur @BMJ_latest bit.ly/wt3iyg 2 years ago
- From @KevinMD, a bleak look at the future of #primarycare bit.ly/wOh0MW 2 years ago
- @aviksaroy Great idea to integrate VA into rest of the system. I also didn't know you went to medical school until reading this article! 2 years ago
- Campaign-finance restrictions as a cause of political polarization? econ.st/znc1xU 2 years ago